Who has the Worst Pain

During the 28 years I have been interacting with bereaved people, one of the most frequent questions I have been asked is, "Who has the worst pain?" Do bereaved parents suffer more than widows and widowers? Do children whose parents die feel more agony than children who lose a sibling? Is it harder to watch a loved one suffer for a long time before death releases the victim than it is to answer the doorbell or the phone at midnight and suddenly hear the news of tragedy? Is suicide worse than homicide? Is the death of an "older" child more difficult to grieve than the death of a newborn or infant?

If there were one, clear and definitive answer to those questions, grieving could be neatly catalogued and mourners could be organized into convenient categories. Our comforters and caregivers would then be able to select from a predictable menu of helps, and everyone could get "healed" more quickly and efficiently. If only....

But the truth is it makes little difference how our loved ones died, at what ages, or what our relationships were named. The pain of grief is agony no matter how or when it happens.

Long-term dying is not better or worse than sudden death-it is different.

Mourning the death of an infant is not better or worse than mourning the death of a teenager-it is different.

The grief of the widowed is not better or worse than the grief of bereaved parents-it is different.

Death by homicide is not easier or harder than death by suicide-it is different. And the list goes on and on?

There is no adequate preparation for the loneliness and emptiness that must be squarely faced when we finally come to the realization that we will never again in this life see that one who is so precious to us. In every case the mourning period can be just as painful and difficult for one as it is for another, but the grief needs of the bereaved can be very different.

When the relationship to a loved one was cemented with the permanent "super glue" of devotion and commitment, death causes a ripping apart that leaves the survivor with a devastating and gaping wound, regardless of how the death occurred or what the relationship was named.

However, if the adhesive that formed the relationship bond was simply "pressure sensitive," the separation may involve no more than the sting of tape being quickly pulled off skin. The pain may be sharp but short-lived, regardless of the type of death or the kind of connection. It all depends on how bonded the survivor was to the deceased.

In our society, a "friendship" may not be taken as seriously as a blood relationship; an engagement may not be perceived as importantly as a marriage; the death of a parent may be assumed to be a more deeply felt loss than it truly was to the surviving child or children. And we must never assume that a long-term dying process has fulfilled the "grief quota" of the survivors who loved and lost!

It's not fair to assume that if mourners have some advance warning that the death is coming, their grieving time is shorter or less intense. We must be careful not to confuse the natural relief that the deceased is finally beyond the reach of suffering with the assumption that the grief of missing them will be abated.

By inadvertently giving our society the message that certain kinds of relationships or certain kinds of experiences are "worse" or "better" than others, the grief support for some survivors may be in danger of being prematurely aborted or even ignored entirely.

Grief is an individual experience and comforters and caregivers must be careful to support the bereaved on a very personal, each-case basis. Mourners feel the pain of grief in direct proportion to their perception of how important the loved one was in their lives, and that value is entirely subjective.

There is really only one criteria that establishes the quality and quantity of mourning: The intensity of grieving is directly related to the intensity of bonding.

Good Grief Resources (http://www.goodgriefresources.com) was conceived and founded by Andrea Gambill whose 17-year-old daughter died in 1976. In 1977, she founded one of the earliest chapters of The Compassionate Friends, an international bereaved-parent support group. In 1987, she founded and edited Bereavement magazine, and in 2000, she joined Centering Corporation as Editor of their new magazine, Grief Digest. Twenty eight years of experience in grief support has provided valuable insights into the unique needs of the bereaved and their caregivers and wide access to many excellent resources.

Related News

ELECTION Q&A: Floyd County Coroner - Evening News and Tribune ELECTION Q&A: Floyd County Coroner Evening News and Tribune, IN -11 hours ago On average two families a day in our community will be touched by the loss of a loved one. As a funeral director and grief counselor I have had the ... Chat Leftovers: Food Processor Bread, Grieving Fare - Washington Post Chat Leftovers: Food Processor Bread, Grieving Fare Washington Post, United States -Oct 9, 2008 Talk to the widow and ask her what she might be craving (recognizing, of course, that she may have a temporary loss of appetite) or what she’d love to have ... X Factor exclusive: Laura White's tears caused by pain of loss - Mirror.co.uk X Factor exclusive: Laura White's tears caused by pain of loss Mirror.co.uk, UK -4 hours ago By Mark Jefferies 11/10/2008 Singer Laura White has revealed the grief behind her X Factor tears – the death of two close relatives. ... Charlotte's loss is our loss, say colleagues - Independent Online Charlotte's loss is our loss, say colleagues Independent Online, South Africa -Oct 9, 2008 "Her loss is our loss. We have given her more than flowers, a person throws flowers away within three or four days, but the moral support we give her will ... Eiko & Koma's non-narrative of loss and love - Minneapolis Star Tribune Eiko & Koma's non-narrative of loss and love Minneapolis Star Tribune, MN -6 hours ago But as they paint ravens on a floor drop, they offer a nubile kind of hope in this stage poem to the ravages of grief, confusion and loss. Victory tinged with pain of personal loss - MLB.com MLB.com Victory tinged with pain of personal loss MLB.com -1 hour ago In the context of such a critical baseball game, none of them had endured a loss so significant. The world of sports has produced a few similar examples, ... Husband's grief over floods tragedy - The Press Association Husband's grief over floods tragedy The Press Association -19 minutes ago A British man has spoken of his grief at the loss of his wife and one of his twin daughters who died after being swept away by floods in Spain. ... Danville service aims to help those who have lost a child - Urbana/Champaign News-Gazette Danville service aims to help those who have lost a child Urbana/Champaign News-Gazette, IL -13 hours ago Padan thinks it's a good thing to have such a ceremony and a place for people who share a common grief to come together. "It's acknowledging a loss that ... Vet's Views - Latah Eagle Vet's Views Latah Eagle, ID -Oct 9, 2008 If you have recently lost a pet, know that you are not alone in your grief. If you know someone who is grieving over the loss of a pet, please realize that ... Ask Amy - Grief: Let your dad help you get over the loss of your ... - Winston-Salem Journal Ask Amy - Grief: Let your dad help you get over the loss of your ... Winston-Salem Journal, NC -6 minutes ago My mom died last year at around this time. I am having a hard time sleeping, and I don't want to eat as much as I used to. My dad tells me it's all stress ...